Key takeaways
- Match the expert to the purpose: tax, litigation, ESOP, SBA lending, financial reporting and M&A each have different requirements and audiences.
- Look for a recognized business valuation credential (such as ABV, CVA, ASA or CBA), relevant industry experience and adherence to professional standards.
- Ask about independence, the type of report (a full valuation or a limited calculation) and testimony experience if the matter could reach court.
- The cheapest report is often the most expensive one if it is rejected by the IRS, a lender or a judge.
A business valuation is only as useful as its credibility with the people who will rely on it, whether that is the IRS, a bankruptcy court, an SBA lender, an ESOP trustee, an auditor or the other side in a dispute. Choosing the right valuation professional is therefore one of the most important decisions in the process. This guide explains what the main credentials mean, which professional standards apply, and what to ask before you engage anyone.
Start with the purpose
| Purpose | What the reader will look for |
|---|---|
| Estate, gift or charitable tax | Fair market value, a “qualified appraiser,” compliance with IRS requirements and case law. See gift and estate tax valuation. |
| SBA lending | Independent valuation from a qualified source, delivered on the lender’s timeline. See SBA business valuations. |
| Litigation (divorce, shareholder disputes, damages) | An expert who can withstand cross-examination and admissibility challenges. See litigation support. |
| ESOPs | Independent appraisal for the trustee, regulatory scrutiny, repurchase obligation analysis. See ESOP valuation services. |
| Financial reporting | Fair value under ASC 820, auditor review, documentation standards |
| M&A, buy-sell agreements, planning | Market insight, practical deal experience, clear communication |
The purpose also determines the standard of value, which an expert should confirm before starting work. See standards of value: fair market value vs. fair value.
Business valuation credentials explained
| Credential | Awarded by | What it signals |
|---|---|---|
| ABV (Accredited in Business Valuation) | AICPA | A CPA (or qualified finance professional) with valuation education, experience and an exam |
| CVA (Certified Valuation Analyst) | NACVA | Valuation training, exam and experience; widely held by CPAs |
| ASA (Accredited Senior Appraiser, Business Valuation) | American Society of Appraisers | Extensive experience, exams, peer-reviewed reports; USPAP education |
| CBA (Certified Business Appraiser) | Originally the Institute of Business Appraisers | Business appraisal experience and peer review |
| CFF (Certified in Financial Forensics) | AICPA | Forensic accounting and litigation support expertise |
| CEIV (Certified in Entity and Intangible Valuations) | Credential supported by AICPA, ASA and RICS | Fair value measurement for financial reporting |
| MAI / SRA | Appraisal Institute | Real estate appraisal expertise (commercial / residential) |
Credentials are not the only measure of competence, but they indicate formal training, testing, continuing education and accountability to an ethics code.
Professional standards to ask about
- AICPA VS Section 100 (Statement on Standards for Valuation Services) for CPA members performing valuation work.
- NACVA Professional Standards for NACVA credential holders.
- USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice), required by the ASA and for many appraisal assignments.
- Revenue Ruling 59-60 and related IRS guidance for tax valuations.
A credible report states the standards followed, the scope of work, the information relied on and the assumptions and limiting conditions.
Valuation engagement vs. calculation engagement
Under AICPA standards, there are two broad types of service:
- Valuation engagement: the analyst applies all approaches and methods considered appropriate and expresses a conclusion of value. This is the right choice for tax filings, litigation and most transactions.
- Calculation engagement: the analyst and client agree on specific approaches or procedures, and the result is a calculated value. It costs less and can be useful for internal planning, but it may not be accepted for tax or court purposes.
Ask which type you are buying, and whether it suits your purpose.
Questions to ask before you hire
- What credentials do you hold, and how much of your practice is valuation?
- How many valuations have you done for this purpose (estate tax, ESOP, divorce, SBA)?
- What industries have you valued? Industry knowledge improves the analysis of risk, margins and comparables.
- Have you testified? If so, how often, in which courts, and have your opinions ever been excluded?
- Are you independent? Any prior relationship with the company, owners or other parties?
- What standards will you follow, and what type of report will I receive?
- What information will you need, and what is the timeline?
- How is the fee determined? Fixed fee, hourly or a range? What could change it?
- Will you be available for questions from the IRS, lender or court after delivery?
- Can I see a redacted sample report?
Red flags
- A fee contingent on the conclusion of value. This compromises independence and is prohibited in many contexts.
- A promised number before any analysis.
- Rule-of-thumb only valuations (for example, “businesses like yours sell for one times revenue”) with no support.
- No discussion of the standard of value, the interest being valued or discounts.
- Unwillingness to explain the methodology in plain English.
- No experience with the purpose or the industry.
Industry and multidisciplinary expertise matters
Some engagements require more than one discipline. A medical practice may involve healthcare regulatory and fair market value compliance issues; a manufacturer may require real estate and equipment appraisals alongside the business valuation; litigation may require forensic accounting. Firms that combine these skills can deliver a consistent, coordinated analysis.
At Foxboro Consulting Group, our team includes:
- Ronald J. Adams, CPA, ABV, CVA, CBA, CFF, with extensive valuation and litigation support experience
- Christopher Sheskier, CPA, ABV, CFF, MBA
- Jude T. Flynn, MAI, SRA, for commercial and residential real estate appraisal
- Paul J. Szklarski, FACHE, for healthcare operations and consulting
You can review our full range of business advisory services and our publications.
What to prepare before your first meeting
- Three to five years of financial statements and tax returns
- Year-to-date interim financial statements
- Organizational documents, shareholder or operating agreements and any buy-sell agreement
- A list of owners and ownership percentages
- Debt schedules, leases and major contracts
- Any prior valuations or offers received
- A short description of the purpose and the deadline
Owners who want a primer before meeting an expert can read DebtRemediationTools.org’s business valuation basics and its overview of buying or selling a business.
Frequently asked questions
There isn’t a single best one. ABV, CVA, ASA and CBA are all widely recognized business valuation credentials. Choose based on the expert’s experience with your purpose and industry, not the credential alone.
Only if they have valuation training and experience, and are independent. Many CPAs specialize in valuation and hold the ABV or CVA credential. Tax preparation alone is not valuation expertise.
Fees depend on the purpose, complexity, the size of the business and the type of report. Litigation and ESOP engagements generally cost more than a calculation for planning. Ask for a written scope and fee estimate.
Often a few weeks once information is received, depending on complexity and responsiveness. Tight lender or court deadlines should be discussed at the outset.
For certain tax purposes, such as charitable contributions, IRS regulations define a qualified appraiser based on recognized credentials or relevant education and experience, plus regular performance of appraisals for compensation. For estate and gift tax, credentials and a well-supported report are strong evidence of reliability.
Next step
Tell us about your purpose and timeline. Contact Foxboro Consulting Group to speak with a credentialed valuation professional.
This article is for general information and is not legal or tax advice. Credential requirements and standards are set by the respective organizations and may change.
foxboro-consulting.com/ · Page


