Quick answer: An earnout is additional purchase price paid only if the acquired business hits future targets, such as revenue or EBITDA. For financial reporting under ASC 805, the buyer records the earnout at fair value on the acquisition date, typically using scenario-based or Monte Carlo models that weigh the probability of each outcome and discount for time and risk. Liability-classified earnouts are remeasured each reporting period.
When buyers and sellers disagree about what a business is worth, an earnout bridges the gap. The seller gets paid more if the business performs as promised; the buyer pays more only if the results arrive. Earnouts are common in acquisitions of growing companies, professional firms, healthcare practices, and technology businesses.
But an earnout is not just a negotiating tool. It must be valued, accounted for, taxed, and administered, and it is one of the most frequent sources of post-closing litigation. This guide explains earnout valuation and how to structure earnouts that work.
Key Takeaways
- An earnout is contingent consideration: future payments that depend on post-closing performance.
- Under ASC 805, buyers measure earnouts at fair value on the acquisition date and include them in the purchase price.
- Earnouts classified as liabilities are remeasured each reporting period, with changes recorded in earnings.
- Valuation methods include scenario-based models, option pricing approaches, and Monte Carlo simulation.
- Clear metrics, accounting rules, and operating covenants reduce disputes.
How Earnouts Are Structured
| Element | Examples |
|---|---|
| Metric | Revenue, gross profit, EBITDA, customer retention, product approval |
| Period | One to five years after closing |
| Payment structure | Fixed payment if a threshold is met, tiered payments, or a percentage of performance above a base |
| Caps and floors | Maximum total earnout; minimum thresholds |
| Catch-up provisions | Shortfalls in one year can be made up in the next |
| Acceleration | Earnout paid in full if the buyer sells the business or breaches covenants |
Revenue-based earnouts are easier to measure but can reward unprofitable growth. EBITDA-based earnouts align with value but invite disputes over expense allocations after integration.
Why Earnouts Must Be Valued
Financial Reporting
Under ASC 805, contingent consideration is part of the consideration transferred and must be recognized at acquisition-date fair value. That value affects goodwill and the purchase price allocation. See our guide to purchase price allocation.
Subsequent Measurement
Earnouts classified as liabilities (usually those paid in cash) are remeasured at fair value each reporting date, with changes running through earnings. Equity-classified earnouts are not remeasured.
Deal Evaluation
Sellers and buyers should understand what an earnout is worth today. A $5 million earnout that is unlikely to be achieved may be worth far less than its face amount. Boards and fairness opinion providers also consider earnout value; see fairness opinions.
Valuation Methods
Scenario-Based Method
The appraiser identifies possible outcomes (for example, low, base, and high performance), assigns probabilities, calculates the payment in each, and discounts the expected payment at an appropriate rate. This is often suitable for simple, binary earnouts.
Option Pricing Method
Earnouts with payments that increase above a threshold behave like options. Option pricing models can capture the asymmetric payoff structure, especially when payments depend on a metric with volatility.
Monte Carlo Simulation
For complex structures, such as multi-year earnouts with caps, catch-ups, and tiered thresholds, Monte Carlo simulation models thousands of possible paths for the underlying metric and calculates the earnout payment in each. This method is widely used when payoffs are path-dependent.
Key Inputs
- Management’s projections of the metric
- Volatility of the metric
- Risk-adjusted discount rate for the metric
- Credit risk of the buyer (the counterparty that must pay)
- Contractual terms: thresholds, caps, timing
Example: Simple Scenario Analysis
A hypothetical buyer agrees to pay a $2 million earnout if the acquired company’s revenue exceeds $15 million in year two.
| Scenario | Probability | Payment |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue below $15M | 45% | $0 |
| Revenue at or above $15M | 55% | $2,000,000 |
| Expected payment | $1,100,000 |
Discounting the $1.1 million expected payment for two years at an appropriate risk-adjusted rate produces a fair value well below the $2 million face amount. That fair value, not $2 million, is recorded at the acquisition date. If performance later improves, the liability increases, and the change is recorded as an expense, which can surprise management teams that expected the earnout to affect only goodwill.
Tax Considerations
Earnout payments are generally treated as additional purchase price for the seller, often reported under the installment method, though payments tied to the seller’s continued employment may be treated as compensation. The purchase agreement and employment terms should be drafted carefully with tax advisors to support the intended treatment.
Avoiding Earnout Disputes
- Define the metric precisely, including accounting principles and adjustments.
- Address integration. Specify how shared costs, transfer pricing, and synergies will be allocated.
- Set operating covenants. Sellers may want commitments that the buyer will operate the business in good faith, maintain staffing, or keep product lines.
- Provide reporting rights so sellers receive regular performance reports.
- Specify dispute resolution, such as review by an independent accountant.
- Address change-of-control acceleration.
Earnouts and the Working Capital Peg
Working capital and earnout calculations both rely on post-closing accounting. Inconsistent policies can affect both. Coordinate definitions with the net working capital peg.
Key Terms Defined
- Contingent consideration: Additional purchase price that depends on future events, such as performance targets.
- Acquisition-date fair value: The value recorded for the earnout at closing under ASC 805.
- Remeasurement: Updating a liability-classified earnout to fair value each reporting period, with changes in earnings.
- Monte Carlo simulation: A modeling technique that runs thousands of possible outcomes to estimate expected payments.
- Catch-up provision: A clause allowing shortfalls in one period to be made up in a later period.
- Operating covenant: A buyer’s promise about how it will run the acquired business during the earnout period.
Common Earnout Mistakes
- Treating the face amount as the value of the earnout.
- Using a metric that the buyer can easily influence after integration.
- Leaving accounting principles for the metric undefined.
- Ignoring the buyer’s credit risk.
- Forgetting that later changes in a liability earnout hit earnings, not goodwill.
Frequently Asked Questions
Rarely. Its fair value reflects the probability of achievement, timing, and the buyer’s credit risk.
Not after the measurement period. Subsequent changes in liability-classified earnouts go through earnings.
Yes, especially when the seller’s projections are aggressive or the business depends on the seller’s relationships. SBA financing has specific limits on earnouts, so check lender rules.
This is a common dispute. The agreement should specify how the metric will be tracked after integration.
An independent valuation professional experienced with contingent consideration and the accounting standards, especially for audited buyers.
Sources and Further Reading
- FASB ASC 805-30 (contingent consideration) and ASC 480 / ASC 815 (classification)
- AICPA Accounting and Valuation Guide: Business Combinations
- Appraisal Foundation, Valuation Advisory on the valuation of contingent consideration
- Internal Revenue Code § 453 (installment sales)
Value the Upside Realistically
Foxboro Consulting Group, Inc. values earnouts and other contingent consideration for purchase price allocations, quarterly remeasurement, and deal negotiations. We help buyers, sellers, and auditors understand what future payments are worth today.
Negotiating or reporting an earnout? Contact Foxboro Consulting Group to model its fair value.


