Key takeaways
- Goodwill arises when a company acquires a business for more than the fair value of its identifiable net assets. Under U.S. GAAP it must be tested for impairment.
- Private companies can elect an accounting alternative: amortize goodwill over up to 10 years and test for impairment only when a triggering event occurs.
- Since ASU 2017-04, the test is a single step: impairment equals the amount by which a reporting unit’s (or entity’s) carrying amount exceeds its fair value, limited to the goodwill balance.
- Fair value is measured under ASC 820, typically using income and market approaches. A supportable valuation is essential for auditors and lenders.
Goodwill is often the largest asset on the balance sheet of a company that has grown by acquisition, and the one most likely to surprise owners when results soften. An unexpected impairment charge can trigger covenant breaches, complicate refinancing and raise questions from auditors and investors. This guide explains how goodwill impairment works for private companies and how to approach it with confidence.
Where goodwill comes from
When a company acquires another business, it allocates the purchase price to identifiable assets and liabilities at fair value under ASC 805. Anything left over is goodwill, representing assembled workforce, expected synergies and other unidentifiable future benefits. See our experience with business combination valuations and purchase price allocations.
Book goodwill is separate from tax goodwill, which follows different rules and is generally amortized over 15 years. See asset sale vs. stock sale.
Two paths for private companies
1. The private company accounting alternative
Introduced by the FASB for private companies (and later extended to not-for-profit entities), this alternative allows a company to:
- Amortize goodwill on a straight-line basis over 10 years, or a shorter period if more appropriate.
- Test for impairment only when a triggering event occurs, rather than annually.
- Elect to test at the entity level rather than for each reporting unit.
A further update allows private companies to evaluate triggering events only as of the end of each reporting period (interim or annual), rather than continuously monitoring throughout the period.
A related alternative lets private companies subsume certain customer-related intangible assets and non-compete agreements into goodwill in an acquisition, simplifying the purchase price allocation.
2. The standard model
Companies that do not elect the alternative do not amortize goodwill. Instead, they test it at least annually at the reporting unit level, and between annual tests if a triggering event occurs.
Triggering events
ASC 350 lists examples of events and circumstances that may indicate that fair value has fallen below carrying amount, including:
- Deterioration in general economic conditions or access to capital
- Industry or market changes, such as increased competition or regulatory change
- Rising costs that hurt profitability
- Declining actual or planned revenue or earnings
- Loss of key personnel or major customers
- Litigation
- A planned sale or disposal of a significant part of the business
- A sustained decrease in share price (for public entities)
Covenant breaches, a significant debt restructuring or a downgrade by a lender are also common practical triggers. DebtRemediationTools.org’s guide to managing business debt describes the cash flow pressures that often precede them.
The impairment test, step by step
Step 0 (optional): qualitative assessment
A company may first assess qualitative factors to determine whether it is more likely than not (over 50%) that fair value is below carrying amount. If not, no further testing is needed.
The quantitative test
- Determine the carrying amount of the reporting unit (or the entity, under the alternative), including goodwill.
- Measure fair value of the reporting unit or entity under ASC 820.
- Compare. If fair value is less than carrying amount, recognize an impairment loss equal to the difference, limited to the goodwill balance.
Before ASU 2017-04, companies had to perform a “Step 2” hypothetical purchase price allocation to measure the loss. That step was eliminated, which simplified the test considerably.
Worked example
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Carrying amount of the entity (including goodwill) | $14,000,000 |
| Goodwill included in carrying amount | $4,000,000 |
| Fair value of the entity | $11,500,000 |
| Shortfall | $2,500,000 |
| Goodwill impairment recognized | $2,500,000 (less than the $4,000,000 goodwill balance) |
If fair value had been $9,000,000, the shortfall would be $5,000,000, but the impairment would be capped at the $4,000,000 of goodwill. Other assets would be tested under their own guidance.
Remember to consider income tax effects, which can affect the calculation where tax-deductible goodwill exists.
Measuring fair value
Fair value under ASC 820 is an exit price from the perspective of market participants. Our article on standards of value explains how this differs from fair market value used for tax. Typical approaches:
- Income approach (discounted cash flow). Based on management’s projections, adjusted to a market participant view, discounted at a rate reflecting market participant risk. See cost of capital for private companies.
- Market approach. Guideline public company multiples and comparable transactions.
- A reconciliation of the two, with a check against any recent transactions or offers.
The methods are described in the three approaches to business valuation. Identifiable intangibles may also need testing; see intangible asset and IP valuation.
Should your company elect the private company alternative?
| Consideration | Alternative (amortize, test on triggers) | Standard model (no amortization, annual test) |
|---|---|---|
| Annual cost and effort | Lower: no annual test, simpler monitoring | Higher: annual testing and documentation |
| Earnings impact | Steady amortization expense each year | No amortization; impairments can be lumpy |
| Risk of a large surprise charge | Lower, because goodwill declines over time | Higher, because goodwill stays on the books at full value |
| Comparability with public peers | Lower | Higher |
| Planning an IPO or sale to a public company | May need to be unwound later | Already aligned with public company reporting |
For most closely held companies with no plans to go public, the alternative reduces cost and complexity. Companies anticipating a public offering, or being acquired by a public company, should discuss the implications with their auditors first, since public business entities cannot use the alternative.
Common practical pitfalls
- Ignoring the trigger. A lost major customer or a covenant waiver is documented in board minutes, but no one evaluates goodwill.
- Testing at the wrong level. Reporting units must be identified consistently with how the business is managed, unless the entity-level election is made.
- Carrying amount errors. Omitting deferred taxes, or assigning assets and liabilities inconsistently between reporting units.
- Hockey-stick projections. A sudden recovery assumed in year two with no operational explanation.
- Discount rates that ignore company size and risk. Using a large-company rate for a small private business overstates fair value.
What auditors and lenders look for
- Projections that reconcile with budgets, board materials and recent performance.
- A discount rate supported by market data, with company-specific risk explained.
- Market evidence that corroborates the income approach.
- Consistency with prior-year assumptions, or clear explanations for changes.
- Documentation that a reviewer can follow.
Business consequences of impairment
An impairment is a non-cash charge, but it reduces book equity and reported earnings. It can:
- Breach net worth or leverage covenants in loan agreements
- Affect bonding capacity for contractors
- Change ratios relied on by investors and surety companies
Discuss potential impairments with lenders early. Plain-English background on valuation concepts for owners is available in DebtRemediationTools.org’s business valuation basics.
Frequently asked questions
Not if they elect the private company alternative. Under the alternative, they amortize goodwill and test only when a triggering event occurs. Without the alternative, testing is required at least annually.
As the amount by which the carrying amount of the reporting unit (or entity) exceeds its fair value, limited to the amount of goodwill. The former two-step test has been eliminated.
An event or change in circumstances that makes it more likely than not that fair value is below carrying amount, such as declining earnings, loss of a key customer, adverse industry changes or a planned sale.
No. Under U.S. GAAP, once goodwill impairment is recognized, it cannot be reversed in later periods.
Management is responsible for the estimate, but most private companies engage an independent valuation specialist to support it for auditors and lenders.
Next step
Facing a potential impairment or an auditor’s questions? Contact Foxboro Consulting Group for independent fair value measurements and business enterprise valuations.
This article is for general information and is not accounting advice. Consult your auditors and the current FASB Accounting Standards Codification for requirements applicable to your entity.
foxboro-consulting.com/ · Page


