Key takeaways
- Key person risk is the risk that a business’s performance will decline if a critical individual, often the owner, leaves, becomes disabled or dies.
- Valuators may reflect key person risk through a higher discount rate, a lower multiple, adjusted cash flow projections, or a separate key person discount.
- The IRS recognizes the concept in Revenue Ruling 59-60, and the U.S. Tax Court has accepted key person discounts in cases such as Estate of Feldmar and Estate of Mitchell.
- Key person risk can be mitigated by building management depth, documenting processes, diversifying relationships, using employment and non-compete agreements, and carrying key person insurance.
- Reducing owner dependence is one of the most effective ways to increase business value before a sale or succession.
Many successful private companies share a common trait: they are built around one remarkable person. The founder knows every major customer by name, designs the products, negotiates with suppliers, solves the hard problems and holds the culture together.
That person is often the reason the business succeeded. They can also be the reason a buyer offers less than expected, or why an appraiser applies a discount in an estate tax valuation.
This article explains how key person risk affects value and what owners can do about it.
What is key person risk?
A key person is an individual whose contributions are so important that losing them would materially harm the business. Key people may contribute: – relationships with customers, referral sources, suppliers or lenders; – technical expertise or intellectual property; – sales and business development ability; – reputation and credibility in the industry; – operational knowledge that isn’t documented; or – leadership that holds the team together.
Key person risk is highest in: – owner-operated small and mid-sized businesses; – professional practices (medical, dental, legal, accounting); – businesses built on personal relationships, such as distribution, brokerage and consulting; – creative and technical businesses dependent on a founder’s talent; and – companies with thin management teams.
Why buyers and appraisers care
Value is based on expected future cash flows and the risk of achieving them. If cash flows depend on someone who may not be there in the future, those cash flows are less certain. The business may be worth less to: – a buyer, who will likely operate without the owner after a transition period; – an heir or successor, if the key person dies or retires; or – a hypothetical buyer under the fair market value standard used for tax purposes.
Key person dependence is closely tied to personal goodwill, which may leave with the individual. See our article on personal vs. enterprise goodwill.
How valuators measure key person risk
There is no single formula. Analysts typically use one or more of the following, taking care not to double count the same risk.
1. Adjusting cash flows
The analyst may project the cash flows the business would generate without the key person, for example, lower revenue from lost relationships, plus the cost of hiring replacement management at market compensation. The normalization of owner compensation is often part of this analysis.
2. Increasing the discount rate
Under the income approach, key person dependence can be reflected in a company-specific risk premium added to the discount or capitalization rate. See our article on cost of capital for private companies.
Example: A company expects free cash flow of $1,030,000 next year, growing at 3% long term.
| Without key person adjustment | With 3% company-specific premium | |
|---|---|---|
| Discount rate | 18% | 21% |
| Capitalization rate (discount rate − growth) | 15% | 18% |
| Indicated value | $6,866,667 | $5,722,222 |
| Reduction | About 16.7% |
A three-percentage-point increase in the discount rate reduces value by about one-sixth in this simplified example.
3. Lowering the market multiple
Under the market approach, a company with heavy owner dependence typically warrants a lower multiple than comparable companies with deeper management. See our article on EBITDA multiples.
4. Applying a separate key person discount
In some valuations, particularly for gift and estate tax purposes after a key person’s death, analysts apply a discount to the value otherwise indicated, reflecting the specific loss.
What the IRS and courts say
Revenue Ruling 59-60, the IRS’s foundational guidance on valuing closely held businesses, recognizes that the loss of a “key man” may depress the value of a business, and that the analyst should consider whether there is adequate management to replace the key person, as well as offsets such as life insurance.
The U.S. Tax Court has accepted key person discounts in several cases, including: – Estate of Feldmar v. Commissioner (1988): The court accepted a 25% key person discount on the value of an insurance company after the death of its founder, after considering factors like life insurance proceeds. – Estate of Mitchell v. Commissioner (2002): Involving the estate of Paul Mitchell, co-founder of the hair care company John Paul Mitchell Systems, the court applied a 10% key person discount.
Other cases have rejected or reduced key person discounts where the analysis double counted risk already reflected in the discount rate or multiple, where management depth was adequate, or where the evidence was weak. The size of any discount depends on the facts and the quality of the analysis. See our article on business valuation for gift and estate tax.
Factors that increase or reduce key person risk
| Increases risk | Reduces risk |
|---|---|
| Owner manages most customer relationships | Account managers own relationships |
| Owner is primary salesperson | Established sales team and marketing |
| Undocumented processes | Documented systems and procedures |
| No second-in-command | Capable successor identified |
| Owner holds critical licenses or certifications | Multiple licensed professionals |
| No employment or non-compete agreements | Agreements with key employees |
| No key person insurance | Insurance proceeds available to offset disruption |
| Customer contracts tied to the individual | Contracts with the company, assignable |
How to reduce key person risk and increase value
1. Build a management team
Hire or develop leaders for sales, operations and finance. Give them real authority, and let customers and suppliers see them leading.
2. Transfer relationships
Introduce other team members to key customers, suppliers and referral sources. Gradually shift day-to-day relationship management.
3. Document everything
Capture processes, pricing logic, technical knowledge and operating procedures in writing. Systems that run without the owner are worth more.
4. Formalize agreements
Use employment agreements, non-competes (where enforceable) and non-solicitation agreements with key employees. Put customer contracts in the company’s name.
5. Diversify revenue
Reduce dependence on a few customers that are loyal to the owner personally.
6. Carry key person insurance
Key person life and disability insurance can provide funds to recruit replacements, cover lost profits and reassure lenders. Valuators consider insurance proceeds as a potential offset to a key person discount.
7. Plan succession
Create a written succession plan, even if the owner has no plans to leave. See our article on succession planning for family businesses.
8. Test the business
Take a real vacation. If the business struggles, you’ve identified where dependence lies.
Timing: start years before a transaction
Reducing key person risk takes time. Buyers want to see a track record of the business performing with less owner involvement. Starting two to three years before a sale gives the strategy time to show results. Our pre-transaction valuation roadmap covers preparation steps.
Frequently asked questions
There is no standard percentage. Courts have accepted a range of discounts depending on the facts, and rejected discounts that weren’t well supported or that double counted risk.
Not necessarily, but insurance proceeds can offset some of the financial impact and are considered in the analysis.
They are related. Personal goodwill is value attributable to an individual; key person risk is the risk that value declines if that individual leaves.
Through lower prices, earnouts, longer transition periods, consulting agreements, non-competes, and retention agreements with key employees.
The bottom line
A business that depends on one person is a business at risk, and buyers, lenders and the IRS all recognize it. The good news is that key person risk is one of the most controllable value drivers. Building a team, transferring relationships and documenting systems can make a business more valuable, more resilient and easier to transition.
Foxboro Consulting Group, Inc. helps owners understand what drives the value of their business and how to improve it, through business enterprise valuations, succession planning and transaction advisory services. Contact us to start the conversation.
This article is for general informational purposes and does not constitute tax, legal or valuation advice. Case outcomes depend on specific facts.


